To make high-quality research more accessible and easier to explore.

Fields:
10 results

Pattern Recognition, Hypotheses Generation, and Auditor Performance in an Analytical Task

The Accounting Review 1991 66(3), 622-642
[Professional standards for analytical procedures call for auditors to hypothesize likely causes of unexpected patterns in financial statement balances and to develop plans to investigate (SAS 56). Therefore, audit efficiency and effectiveness depend on competency in recognizing patterns in financial data and in hypothesizing likely causes of those patterns to serve as a guide for further testing. Yet our knowledge of how well auditors accomplish these crucial steps has been limited by the difficulty of developing research tasks with criteria for evaluating auditor performance. The purpose of this study is to relate processes of pattern recognition and hypothesis generation to quality of performance in an analytical task. To accomplish this purpose, we conducted a laboratory study in which 21 auditors were asked to think aloud while performing an analytical procedures task. The case contained a seeded error that caused a fairly complex pattern of discrepancies between projected and unaudited financial ratios and balances. Think-aloud verbal protocols provided a trace of subjects' reasoning processes, and the seeded error provided an outcome criterion to evaluate the hypotheses they generated. This design supplies evidence needed to evaluate pattern recognition and hypothesis generation processes that lead to correct and incorrect outcomes. Results indicated that three auditors made acquisition errors and four failed to combine crucial cues into a pattern. Of the 14 auditors who recognized the pattern, six proposed a hypothesis consistent with the pattern. Thus, hypothesis generation was the stage at which process errors most frequently occurred, and the least experienced auditors had the most difficulty at that stage. Specific process problems that inhibited generation of a correct hypothesis included: addressing only part of a recognized pattern, and/or fixating on a certain error type. Thus, protocol analysis allowed insight into which stages in the process proved most difficult for the auditors and why, providing a focus for further research and decision aid development. This research responds to the call for inclusion of criterion outcomes in audit judgment research (e.g., Libby 1981; Ashton 1982; Biggs 1985; Davis and Solomon 1989). The importance of criterion outcomes can be seen in the advances made in decision research in medicine (e.g., Johnson et al. 1982; Patel and Groen 1986; Lesgold et al. 1988). and physics (e.g., Chi et al. 1982; Robertson 1990). In medicine especially, the ability to relate diagnostic processes to outcome quality has contributed to the theory and practice of medical decision making (Kassirer 1989) in ways that have been unavailable in auditing.]

Strategic Considerations for Unaudited Account Values in Analytical Review

The Accounting Review 1990 65(1), 227-241
[Recent research indicates that auditors' account value estimates from analytical review are affected by knowledge of the unaudited account value (or book value). The exact nature of the consequences from the auditor's use of book value for analytical review has not been formally shown and is a source of controversy. This paper examines the audit cost and risk consequences associated with the auditor's reliance on book value for analytical review. The analysis is framed within a Bayesian decision theoretic model and is conducted for a comprehensive set of audit and environmental conditions. The results include expressions for audit cost/risk when the auditor's analytical review is and is not conditioned on book value. While definitive inferences are possible only when certain intuitive criteria are used, the advantages of incorporating book value in the practice of analytical review appear minimal. That is, reliance on book value would seem to require a procedure that, if reliable, would preclude the need for analytical review (or any other audit procedures).]

An Investigation of Auditor Judgment in Analytical Review

The Accounting Review 1985 60(4), 607-633
[Experiments involving variations on two analytical review task situations were used to assess practicing auditors' judgments. The first experiment required auditors to generate expected values and noninvestigation intervals given variations in the amount of audited information available and the presence or absence of unaudited information. Consistent with prior research, the auditors' judgments were biased in the direction of the unaudited information. However, this bias was moderated when additional audited information was available. The second experiment required auditors to extrapolate intuitively an expected value for an account, given six different deterministic time-series patterns. The auditors' extrapolations were more accurate for those time-series patterns that are more likely to be encountered in practice. That is, extrapolations were slightly more accurate for increasing trends than decreasing trends, and were more accurate for linear and logarithmic patterns than exponential patterns. Implications for research and practice are discussed.]

Auditor's Use of Analytical Review in Audit Program Design.

The Accounting Review 1988 63(1), 148-161
This research presents some descriptive evidence of how auditors perform analytical review in a complex and realistic task setting. Specifically, the research investigates how auditors who differ in terms of experience, design and conduct analytical review and revise audit programs in light of their analytical review judgments. To accomplish this purpose, a comprehensive case was administered to four auditors who performed the task while thinking aloud. The results show that both managers and seniors identified the crucial audit problems embedded in the case. However, there was little evidence that analytical review provided a basis for reducing the extent of planned substantive audit procedures even in audit areas where reduction seemed to be warranted. Also, several important behavioral differences were observed in the information acquisition and decision behavior of the managers and seniors. Some of these differences are consistent with differences found in studies of physics experts and novices can be attributed to constructs in human memory and reasoning research. Interestingly, the protocols produced almost no evidence of the use of probabilistic reasoning (e.g., Bayesian inference) by any of the auditors. However, there is evidence of their use of the kinds of reasoning processes being proposed and evaluated in artificial intelligence research.

Auditor's Use of Analytical Review in Audit Program Design

The Accounting Review 1988 63(1), 148-161
[This research presents some descriptive evidence of how auditors perform analytical review in a complex and realistic task setting. Specifically, the research investigates how auditors who differ in terms of experience, design and conduct analytical review and revise audit programs in light of their analytical review judgments. To accomplish this purpose, a comprehensive case was administered to four auditors who performed the task while thinking aloud. The results show that both managers and seniors identified the crucial audit problems embedded in the case. However, there was little evidence that analytical review provided a basis for reducing the extent of planned substantive audit procedures even in audit areas where reduction seemed to be warranted. Also, several important behavioral differences were observed in the information acquisition and decision behavior of the managers and seniors. Some of these differences are consistent with differences found in studies of physics experts and novices can be attributed to constructs in human memory and reasoning research. Interestingly, the protocols produced almost no evidence of the use of probabilistic reasoning (e.g., Bayesian inference) by any of the auditors. However, there is evidence of their use of the kinds of reasoning processes being proposed and evaluated in artificial intelligence research.]

Pattern Recognition, Hypotheses Generation, and Auditor Performance in an Analytical Task.

The Accounting Review 1991 66(3), 622-642
The article relates processes of pattern recognition and hypotheses generation to auditors' quality of performance in an analytical task. Professional standards for analytical procedures call for auditors to hypothesize likely causes of unexpected patterns in financial statement balances and to develop plans to investigate. Therefore, audit efficiency and effectiveness depend on competency in recognizing patterns in financial data and in hypothesizing likely causes of those patterns to serve as a guide for further testing. In the article, researchers conducted a laboratory study in which 21 auditors were asked to think aloud while performing an analytical procedures task. The case contained a seeded error that caused a fairly complex pattern of discrepancies between projected and unaudited financial ratios and balances. Think-aloud verbal protocols provided a trace of subjects' reasoning processes, and the seeded error provided an outcome criterion to evaluate the hypotheses they generated. This design supplies evidence needed to evaluate pattern recognition and hypothesis generation processes that lead to correct and incorrect outcomes.

Strategic Considerations for Unaudited Account Values in Analytical Review.

The Accounting Review 1990 65(1), 227-241
Recent research indicates that auditors' account value estimates from analytical review are affected by knowledge of the unaudited account value (or book value). The exact nature of the consequences from the auditor's use of book value for analytical review has not been formally shown and is a source of controversy. This paper examines the audit cost and risk consequences associated with the auditor's reliance on book value for analytical review. The analysis is framed within a Bayesian decision theoretic model and is conducted for a comprehensive set of audit and environmental conditions. The results include expressions for audit cost/risk when the auditor's analytical review is and is not conditioned on book value. While definitive inferences are possible only when certain intuitive criteria are used, the advantages of incorporating book value in the practice of analytical review appear minimal. That is, reliance on book value would seem to require a procedure that, if reliable, would preclude the need for analytical review (or any other audit procedures).

An Investigation of Auditor Judgment in Analytical Review.

The Accounting Review 1985 60(4), 607-633
Experiments involving variations on two analytical review task situations were used to assess practicing auditors' judgments. The first experiment required auditors to generate expected values and noninvestigation intervals given variations in the amount of audited information available and the presence or absence of unaudited information. Consistent with prior research, the auditors' judgments were biased in the direction of the unaudited information. However, this bias was moderated when additional audited information was available. The second experiment required auditors to extrapolate intuitively an expected value for an account, given six different deterministic time-series patterns. The auditors' extrapolations were more accurate for those time-series patterns that are more likely to be encountered in prectice. That is, extrapolations were slightly more accurate for increasing trends than decreasing trends, and were more accurate for linear and logarithmic patterns than exponential patterns. Implications for research and practice are discussed.