Abstract We study depositor behavior and capital flight using data from the Freedman’s Savings Bank, a bank established after the U.S. Civil War to support formerly enslaved individuals. White depositors, who generally had better access to financial information, begin providing significant funding as interest terms are enhanced. They respond faster to postpanic stabilization efforts and negative bank-specific information, and are twice as likely to close accounts before failure, passing expected losses to Black depositors, who were the bank’s primary philanthropic target. Our results show how demand deposit funding of bank-like institutions can create systemic disadvantages for less experienced borrowers.

Using detailed depositor arrival data from the Freedman’s Savings and Trust, we examine how the failure to prevent racial violence impacts bank participation. From 1866 to 1873, we find that events of racial violence perpetrated against Black Americans decrease new account openings at branches in the same region by 25% relative to other branches in the 30 days after the event. Alternatively, events that increased political representation and protections increase the relative arrival of new depositors at the bank by around 50% for the affected branches. We also show that those who opened accounts in the wake of a violent event were less likely to close an account before the bank’s eventual failure, suggesting that those who were resistant to the impact of political violence may have tragically been more exposed to other institutional failures.