Some features of the theory 86. — Expected profits of the firm, 88. — Optimal accuracy of forecasts, 91. — Market equilibrium, 92. — Comparative statics, 92. — Conclusion, 96.
The Review of Economics and Statistics196446(4), 398
ECONOMISTS have been interested in the accuracy of anticipations for two reasons. First, effective countercyclical policy depends on accurate forecasts of future investment, inventories, sales, etc. Second, the degree of accuracy of anticipations has implications about the way anticipations are formed. This paper deals with the accuracy of sales anticipations. The source of the data on anticipations is the Annual Survey of Business Anticipations of Sales collected by the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Department of Commerce. The only systematic study of these data has been conducted by Modigliani and Weingartner.2 In the first section, we test whether sales anticipations are more accurate than the forecasts of several naive models and whether anticipations correctly predict the direction of change of sales. Next, we test Theil's hypothesis that predictions refer to a shorter period than they are supposed to. In the last section of the paper, an accuracy measure proposed by Theil is adopted to determine (1) whether an accurate forecaster is less likely to commit systematic forecasting errors and (2) whether anticipations conform to the rational expectations hypothesis. Nature of the Data
The frequency of sales has increased dramatically in recent years. Paradoxically, the percentage markup has also increased. Markdowns and markups are higher in some departments of department stores than in others. The major theme of the paper is that the growing role of fashion and product variety is an important reason for these increases and for the differences between merchandise groups.
The theory of clearance sales is expanded and applied to explain why markups, markdowns, and the frequency of sales of merchandise sold by department stores have increased dramatically in recent years and why they differ across merchandise groups. Tha major theme of the paper is that the growing role of fashion and product variety is an important reason for these increases and for the differences between merchandise groups. The growing importance of fashion is illustrated by documenting the declining use of whites and the increasing use of colors and prints. Estimates of the effects of imports, and technological and demographic changes on markups and markdowns, are presented.
A self-interest explanation is presented for opposition by some farm groups to futures markets. During the twenties and thirties political opposition to futures markets was greater in the grain-producing states. The opposition was centered in Minnesota, North Dakota, South Dakota, Montana, and a few other states. The line elevator companies were prominent in these states and not others and used futures prices to facilitate a buying cartel. Futures prices were used to derive a suggested buying price for elevator purchases in each local market. The political opposition to futures by farmers was designed to raise the cost of operating local cartels. Political opposition was greater and gross profit margins of elevators were higher in states with line elevators.
A self-interest explanation is presented for opposition by some farm groups to futures markets. During the twenties and thirties political opposition to futures markets was greater in the grain-producing states. The opposition was centered in Minnesota, North Dakota, South Dakota, Montana, and a few other states. The line elevator companies were prominent in these states and not others and used futures prices to facilitate a buying cartel. Futures prices were used to derive a suggested buying price for elevator purchases in each local market. The political opposition to futures by farmers was designed to raise the cost of operating local cartels. Political opposition was greater and gross profit margins of elevators were higher in states with line elevators.
The reasons for the shift from private to public ownership of urban transit facilities are the subject of the paper. The regulation theory suggests that this shift is due to the increasing severity of regulation, while the declining-market and externalities hypotheses suggest that increases in automobile ownership are the reason for reduced profits and public ownership. Regression results indicate that profit margins of privately owned systems are higher when regulation is by a state rather than a local agency. Changes in profit margins over time are found to be directly related to increases in automobile ownership.
The reasons for the shift from private to public ownership of urban transit facilities are the subject of the paper. The regulation theory suggests that this shift is due to the increasing severity of regulation, while the declining-market and externalities hypotheses suggest that increases in automobile ownership are the reason for reduced profits and public ownership. Regression results indicate that profit margins of privately owned systems are higher when regulation is by a state rather than a local agency. Changes in profit margins over time are found to be directly related to increases in automobile ownership.
The Review of Economics and Statistics196244(1), 82
FIRM turnover, that is, the change in rank among the leading firms, has had a long, if undistinguished, history as a measure of competition. To the best of our knowledge, it was first proposed by Rufus S. Tucker 1 in I936 and later used by Edwin B. George.2 In I953 A. D. H. Kaplan and Alfred E. Kahn 3 revived interest in the measure and more recently it has been applied by Jules Joskow.4 Recent work on the growth rate of firms by P. E. Hart and S. J. Prais,5 and H. A. Simons and C. P. Bonini 6 has led them to encourage its use, not merely as a supplement to concentration ratios but as a replacement. The Kaplan and Kahn results were subject to a barrage of criticism. Stigler,7 Markham 8 and Adelman I pointed out serious errors of fact and interpretation. But the usefulness of the turnover concept itself has not been questioned. The purpose of this article is to examine the turnover concept, to suggest that it is not very useful, and to propose another measure which is, in the authors' view, more defensible from the viewpoint of both economic and statistical theory.