To make high-quality research more accessible and easier to explore.

Fields:
2 results ✕ Clear filters

Performance Targets and Ex Post Incentive Plan Adjustments†

Contemporary Accounting Research 2022 39(2), 863-892
Performance evaluations are typically based on a formula that specifies in advance all performance measures, their relative incentive weights, and targets to be met. However, beginning‐of‐year performance targets can become outdated due to unforeseen events that call for ex post adjustments to formula‐based incentive plans to restore incentives. We discuss three types of ex post incentive plan adjustments—end‐of‐year subjective performance evaluation, changes in next‐year relative incentive weights, and changes in next‐year performance targets—and empirically examine the extent to which they are used to discourage failure to meet a target by a wide margin. Specifically, we use 2004–2015 data on formula‐based bonus plans, subjective performance evaluations, and performance in Korean state‐owned enterprises. Consistent with our predictions, we find that very low performance relative to target is associated with (i) low subjective evaluations and (ii) an increase in next‐year incentive weights, conditions that render areas with poor performance more important in future evaluations. These findings are more pronounced on performance dimensions of high importance and less pronounced when very low performance is due to an adverse uncontrollable shock. Finally, we find evidence that ex post incentive plan adjustments are associated with future performance improvements. Combined, our findings suggest that ex post incentive plan adjustments can be used to strengthen incentives when performance targets get outdated.

Relative Performance Evaluation and the Ratchet Effect

Contemporary Accounting Research 2018 35(4), 1702-1731
When targets depend on past performance, incentives are adversely affected by the ratchet effect. We provide theory and evidence that incorporating past peer performance into targets can alleviate this adverse incentive effect. In particular, we present an analytical model that characterizes optimal target revisions as a function of past own and past peer performance. We then test the predictions of our model using data on 2008–2010 performance targets from 354 units of a governmental agency responsible for reintegration of the long‐term unemployed into the labor market. As a unique feature of our data, we have information on peer group quality, defined as the extent to which peer performance is informative about common shocks. Consistent with our model, we find that higher peer group quality (a) increases sensitivity of target revisions to past peer performance, (b) reduces sensitivity of target revisions to past own performance, and (c) reduces the ratchet effect as reflected in managerial incentives to withhold end‐of‐year effort.