On the Disaggregation of Excess Demand Functions
[We solve the problem of the restrictions imposed on the Jacobian A at prices p̄ of the aggregate excess demand function x(p) of m agents in an exchange economy with l commodities, under the assumption of individual rationality. Given an arbitrary differentiable function x(p) satisfying homogeneity and Walras' law, we attribute rational individual excess demand functions x^1 (p), ..., x^m (p) to the m agents such that at any arbitrarily specified vector p̄ aggregate excess demand is equal to x(p̄) and the following condition is satisfied: There exists a subspace M of dimension m such that the Jacobian at p̄ of x(p) and the Jacobian at p̄ of the aggregate excess demand function define the same linear function on M. If x(p̄) ≠ 0, M can be taken to have dimension (m+1). As an immediate consequence of our proof for m=1 we show that even if p̄, x(p̄), and Dx(p̄) are known for the excess demand function of a single agent, the substitution effect and the income effect cannot be unambiguously determined without knowledge of the utility function. We extend the results proved at a point to large open neighborhoods. We show that if x(p) is an arbitrary function which bounded from below and satisfies homogeneity and Walras' law, and if x(p̄) ≠ 0, then we can find an open neighborhood G of p̄ and (l-1) individually rational excess demand functions x^1(p), ..., x^l-l (p), such that Σ_k=1^l-1 x^k (p) = x(p) everywhere on G.]