For some time there has been disagreement among financial economists as to the effect of dividend policy on the valuation of a firm under conditions of uncertainty. On one side of the debate Miller and Modigliani (MM) [11] argue that the capitalization rate on shares is independent of the dividend policy of the firm. Gordon [6], [7], [8], and others, on the other hand, reject this proposition and present theories of valuation where share prices and capitalization rates are very much dependent upon the dividend policies of firms.

Careful examination of the behavior of financial variables over time uncovers an important distinction: variables expressed in dollars, such as earnings per share, behave very differently from percentage changes in those same variables. Similarly, financial ratios, such as the price/earnings ratio, behave quite differently from percentage changes in financial ratios. Variables expressed in dollars and financial ratios appear comparatively stable and predictable over time. Successive values are fair approximations of one another. Percentage changes in dollar and financial ratio variables-i.e., growth variables on the other hand, tend to be erratic, volatile, and unpredictable over time. Successive values bear little relation to one another. This distinction between dollar and ratio variables, on the one hand, and percentage changes in these variables-i.e., growth variables-on the other, serves as a useful basis for a financial model.

The results of this study indicate that the individual common stocks in the Dow-Jones. Industrial Average were not consistent inflation hedges. Assuming an 8.2 percent normal required rate of return, none of the common stocks was a complete inflation hedge during all three recent inflationary periods tested. Even assuming a zero normal required rate of return á la traditional investment theory, only six (20 percent) of the thirty common stocks sampled were inflation hedges during all three inflationary periods.

George M. Frankfurter, Herbert E. Phillips, John P. Seagle, Portfolio Selection: The Effects of Uncertain Means, Variances, and Covariances, The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol. 6, No. 5 (Dec., 1971), pp. 1251-1262