Knowledge that Transforms

To make high-quality research more accessible and easier to explore.

Fields:
117 results ✕ Clear filters

Two Propositions Related to Public Goods

The Review of Economics and Statistics 1958 40(4), 329
PpT HIS note, pertinent to some recent literature on public goods,' presents two propositions which place the question of the optimal expenditure levels for public goods in a somewhat different perspective. By (pure) public goods or, synonymously, (pure) collective consumption goods, we mean those consumer goods having the property that, once produced, their enjoyment by each and every individual does not reduce their availability for the enjoyment of others. Public defense and public health measures may suggest cases in point.

Primary Employment Effects of Alternative Spending Programs

The Review of Economics and Statistics 1958 40(4), 319
COUNTERCYCLICAL effects of public expenditures have received voluminous treatment in the economic literature of the past thirty years. There is one significant area, however, where improved data and analytical tools may provide new understanding. This is the area of public expenditure effects on employment and industrial output throughout the economy. The question of economy-wide effects was of considerable concern to early analysts of government work and relief programs. Early studies of these effects ordinarily began with a limited number of final materials and laboriously traced their production back through intermediate stages. In contrast to these earlier methods, input-output analysis, as introduced in Professor Leontief's The Structure of the American Economy in I94I, started with a comprehensive picture of the production relationships among all industries and provided a formal technique for tracing out economy-wide production and employment repercussions. The Bureau of Labor Statistics extended Leontief's empirical work into the postwar era, and in I952 published the results of a massive and detailed study of interindustry relationships for the year I947.' The present study uses the same interindustry data to investigate the employment effects of a variety of possible government spending programs. These include several types of public works, defense procurement (195I pattern), and general government spending at both the national and local levels. In most cases these spending patterns were those observed for the year I947, but some material for I954 was also available. Because government policies can also influence expenditures in other parts of the economy, the analysis has been extended to private house construction, all industrial construction, consumer spending (which may be increased through tax cuts, expanded government payrolls, or direct relief payments), and private capital investment. The analysis of these expenditure patterns, however, is of interest to countercyclical policy only to the extent that government policies actually do bring about the type of spending described. Finally, averages for all new construction (1947 pattern), all maintenance construction, and Professor Leontief's earlier results on foreign trade are included for comparison.

Statistical Cost Functions: A Re-Appraisal

The Review of Economics and Statistics 1958 40(4), 339
Обсуждаются критические замечания, высказывавшиеся в отношении утверждений о зависимости между выпуском продукции и затратами на ее производство. Разбор проведен на основе статистического анализа реальных данных (как в кратко-, так и в долгосрочном периоде).

A Theory of the Responsiveness of Hours of Work to Changes in Wage Rates

The Review of Economics and Statistics 1958 40(2), 116
A T one time the proposition that an increase in the wage rate would call forth a smaller number of hours of work from an individual laborer was evidently accepted by economists without qualification. For example, Professor Pigou in I920, arguing that the imposition of a tax on a laborer (the opposite of a wage increase) would result in his working more hours, wrote: Since a part of his income is taken away, the last unit of income that is left to him will be desired more urgently than the last unit of income that would have been left to him if there had been no taxation. But the last unit of energy that he devotes to work will not affect him differently from what it did. Consequently, there will be a tendency for him to work a little harder than he would have done otherwise. 1 Again in I928, Professor Pigou put the same arguments more specifically. Then, since income is taken away from the taxpayers, the marginal utility of money to them is raised, but the marginal disutility of work is unchanged. And Professor Pigou continued with a statement on the attainment of an equilibrium position: Hence, unless they are somehow impeded, they will increase the amount of work done, and so of income obtained, up to the point at which the marginal utility of income and the marginal disutility of work done to secure it again become equal-which is obviously the optimum. 2 (Italics in original.) Similarly Professor Knight in I92i argued that if men act rationally, . they will at a higher rate divide their time between wageearning and non-industrial uses in such a way as to earn more money, indeed, but to work fewer hours. 3 (Italics in original.) Both Professor Pigou and Professor Knight based their conclusions on an assumption of diminishing marginal utility of income. The unanimity of expert opinion was broken by Professor Robbins in I930.4 Phrasing his argument in terms of the effort (as distinguished from the money) prices of the goods constituting real income, Professor Robbins pointed out that it is the elasticity of the demand for income with respect to effort that determines the responsiveness of the individual's hours of work to changes in wage rates. If this elasticity is greater than unity, a decrease in wage rates (or the imposition of a tax) will result in fewer hours of labor. If the elasticity is less than unity a decline in wage rates or an increase in taxes will result in more hours of labor.5 Thus Professors Pigou and Knight had implicitly assumed that the elasticity of demand for income in terms of effort is less than unity. Professor Robbins agreed that the deductions of the earlier authors justify the downward slope of a curve representing demand for income in terms of effort prices, but he contended that nothing in their arguments shows that the elasticity of such a curve is necessarily less than unity.6 Professor Paish presented much the same viewpoint as did Professor Robbins, but Professor Paish based his analysis on the demand for leisure, which he treated as a good.7 If income is decreased as a result of an increase in taxation, argued Professor Paish, the result may be either to increase or to decrease a person's demand for leisure. Assuming a flat rate tax increase or a decrease in hourly wages, both aggregate income and marginal income decline. The decline in aggregate income will cause a person to demand fewer hours of leisure. The decrease in marginal income, however, will have the opposite effect; it reduces the cost of addi-

Monetary Theories of the Rate of Interest: A Dynamic Analysis

The Review of Economics and Statistics 1958 40(1), 15
DESPITE extensive controversy and discussion,1 the subject of monetary interest theory still seems to involve a considerable residue of confusion and uncertainty. While the writer does not pretend to be able to unsnarl all the tangled threads of this complex subject, it is hoped that the analysis presented here will serve three somewhat interrelated purposes: (i) to clarify the relation between the Keynesian liquidity preference theory and the loanable funds theory espoused by Robertson, Haberler, and others; (2) to produce a clearer understanding of the relation between stock and flow analysis in monetary theory; and (3) to develop an important distinction between (a) the determination of the rate of interest in a short period when the level of income is not in equilibrium, and (b) the forces that explain the change that occurs in the rate of interest during a longer period as the level of income moves from one equilibrium position to another.

A New Approach to the Construction of Index Numbers

The Review of Economics and Statistics 1958 40(3), 240
T HE importance of fluctuations in index numbers as guides to the formulation of economic policy decisions hardly requires emphasis. Changes in Federal Reserve policy, for example, are based, at least in part, upon price level variations, as measured either by the BLS consumer price index or by the index of wholesale prices. Similarly, many of the economic time series used by the Council of Economic Advisers as indicators of the state of the economy or of fundamental trends within the system are index numbers. And, to an ever increasing extent, the incomes of significant portions of our economy are adjusted periodically in response to movements in price indexes. spite of this situation, these indexes, which underlie so much of our economic life, are basically inadequate as quantitative measures of change. For, first of all, the solution to the problem of correct weighting of the members of the sample is not at all obvious.' But, in addition, the construction of an index number is normally associated with the selection, on an a priori basis, of the sample of commodities which is to be utilized in the evaluation of the index.2 use of such a judgment sample precludes the determination of the extent to which an observed difference in two indexes can be ascribed to sampling errors, rather than to real causes. This defect is extremely important, since index numbers are generally employed for intertemporal, interregional, or intersectoral comparisons, where differences are often quite small, and their significance correspondingly uncertain. Furthermore, the use of an arbitrary fixed sample permits neither changes in product quality nor the introduction or disappearance of consumer products readily to be incorporated into the standard type of index. Any attempt to take such effects into account must of necessity impair the continuity of the index through time. At present, the author knows of no method in use which will allow the realistic evaluation of the statistical errors associated with an index number. view of the practical significance of this problem, it is suggested in this paper that the items used in the computation of an index be chosen in a statistical manner. use of a probabilistic sample would, in principle at least, remove all the above mentioned deficiencies inherent in the normal method of sample selection. And, while the proposed procedure would not solve the problem of appropriate weighting, it would have the further advantage of being in conformity with the modern statistical trend towards the replacement of judgment samples by probability samples. order to test whether the use of a sampling procedure governed by the laws of chance would lead to unforeseen practical complications, it seemed advantageous to apply the method suggested, on a small scale, to a more or less realistic situation. Among other information which could be gained from a preliminary investigation of this nature would be an estimate of the magnitude of the sampling variance, as well as hints regarding the difficulties and problems which might arise in full-scale application. * author is indebted for valuable comments to Professors W. L. Crum, R. Dorfman, E. H. Huntington, and G. Kuznetz. Bureau of Business and Economic Research, University of California, Berkeley, kindly financed the study, and Mr. Kenneth J. Oberman aided in the research. 1 For a discussion of this problem see R. Frisch, Some Basic Principles of Price of Living Measurements, Econometrica, xxii (October I954), 505 f.; and M. J. Ulmer, Economic Theory of Cost of Living Index Numbers (New York, I949). 2 Thus, in describing the procedure employed for the selection of the list of goods included in the index, the BLS writes: In I950 and I95I the Bureau priced and studied the price changes of hundreds of items. Using this information and extensive price records of the past, the Bureau selected about 300 items, which together can be used to estimate the average change in prices of all items in the 'market basket.' U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, The Consumer Price Index as revised, I953, Bulletin II40 ('953), 3.