The Review of Economics and Statistics195840(1), 50
Robert E. Baldwin, The Commodity Composition of Trade: Selected Industrial Countries, 1900-1954, The Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 40, No. 1, Part 2. Problems in International Economics (Feb., 1958), pp. 50-68
The Review of Economics and Statistics195840(3), 250
FROM the early days of input-output analysis its practitioners have recognized the importance of the aggregation problem and the fact that the results of the analysis depend upon the particular aggregation procedures used to combine industries. Recently, an increasing number of writers have become interested in theoretical as well as practical aspects of the problem.' The potential user of input-output analysis often needs to reduce a given table to smaller size. table say 200 by 200 or even 50 by 50is cumbersome for many purposes. The theorist finds it too detailed to understand, and the forecaster finds it too extensive to use in making further numerical computations. Of course some information is always lost by aggregation. But the considerations that lead to the computations of averages and index numbers also lead to the consolidation of inputoutput tables: ease of comprehension and economy of manipulation. The following question has been posed in the literature: 2 given a detailed input-output table in which many industries appear, and given the desire of the research worker to have only a few large industries to deal with, when is it possible to consolidate the small industries into industries, and still obtain the results of the analysis or predictions as would have been obtained by using the many small industries in the first place? The answer to this question has been shown to be almost never. The special cases where it is possible have indicated the type of conditions needed for what might be called good aggregation procedures meaning procedures which give approximately the same results as given by the detailed model. The need to develop criteria for good aggregation has been recognized, but few specific suggestions have been made.3 The purpose of this paper is to suggest specific criteria and procedures for good aggregation of a given input-output table. First, reasonable criteria are developed, based on the usual objectives of input-output analysis and on some special assumptions concerning final demand. Some approximations to these criteria are then proposed that are closely related to previous suggestions to aggregate on the basis of similarity of coefficients or homogeneity of input structure. The criteria are then illustrated and the usefulness of the approximations tested by numerical experiments involving a * The author gratefully acknowledges the assistance given him by the Social Science Research Council, which awarded him a Faculty Research Fellowship; the Bureau of Research of Kansas State College; Professor William A. Neiswanger, of the Department of Economics of the University of Illinois; Professor Thomas E. Hull, of the Department of Mathematics of the University of British Columbia; Patricia Kollman, graduate research assistant in the Department of Economics and Sociology of Kansas State College. 'J. B. Balderston and T. M. Whitin, in the Input-Output Model in Oskar Morgenstern, ed., Economic Activity (New York, I954), 79-I28; Tibor Barna, and in Input-Output Analysis in Tibor Barna, ed., The Structural Interdependence of the Economy (Proceedings of an International Conference on Input-Output Varenna, I954), ch. 7; John C. H. Fei, A Fundamental Theorem for the Problem of Input-Output Analysis, Econometrica, xxiv (October I956), 400-I2; M. Hatanaka, Note on Consolidation Within a Leontief System, Econometrica, xx (April 1952), 30I-303; Mathilda Holzman, of Classification and Aggregation in Wassily Leontief, ed., Studies in the Structure of the American Economy (New York, I953), ch. 9; John McCarthy, in the Open Leontief Model (paper presented to the Econometric Society at Cleveland, Ohio, December 1956); M. McManus, General Consistent in Leontief Models, Yorkshire Bulletin, vIII (June I956), 28-48; Edmond Malinvaud, Problems in Input-Output Models in Tibor Barna ed., op. cit., ch. 8; Oskar Morgenstern and Thomson M. Whitin, Comments in National Bureau of Economic Research ed., Input-Output Analysis: An Appraisal (Studies in Income and Wealth, Vol. i8, Princeton, I955), I28-35; Herbert A. Simon and Albert Ando, of Variables in Dynamic Systems (paper presented to the Econometric Society at Cleveland, Ohio, December I956); H. Theil, Linear in Input-Output Analysis, Econometrica, xxv (January I957), III-22. 2See works cited of Balderston and Whitin, Hatanaka, Malinvaud, McManus, Theil. 3Some preliminary suggestions have been made by McCarthy and by Simon and Ando in their papers cited.
The Review of Economics and Statistics195840(1), 111
Wassily W. Leontief, Factor Proportions and the Structure of American Trade: Further Theoretical and Empirical Analysis: Comment, The Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 40, No. 1, Part 2. Problems in International Economics (Feb., 1958), pp. 111-116
The Review of Economics and Statistics195840(4), 332
ECONOMIC theorists have done work of high quality and great quantity in the field of taxation. Public expenditure seems to have been relatively neglected. To illustrate this, let me turn to Professor Pigou. I do so with some diffidence, remembering what Ralph Waldo Emerson said to Oliver Wendell Holmes when Holmes showed him a youthful criticism of Plato. When you strike at a King, Emerson said, sure you kill I have no wish to assassinate Professor Pigou. Nor even to criticize him. But immortality does have its price: if one writes an outstanding treatise such as Pigou's A Study in Public Finance, one must expect other men to swarm about it, picking a nugget here and probing for a weakness there. Of a book of some 285 pages, Pigou devotes most attention to taxes. At least 200 pages to taxes; of the rest, most are concerned with fiscal policy and its impact on the business cycle. What about the pure theory of public expenditure? I can find barely half a dozen pages devoted to the heart of this matter specifically, pages 30-34. And even if we widen the category to include Pigou's definitions of transfer and exhaustive expenditure and his discussion of pricing of state-operated public utilities we still cannot bring the total of pages much beyond twenty. Now it may be that this ratio of 200 on taxes to 20 on expenditure is the proper one. Perhaps there is really nothing much to say about expenditure, and so heavily overbalanced a page budget may be truly optimal. On the other hand, we must admit that fashion has a great influence in economics, which suggests that we ought periodically to survey the neglected areas of theory to make sure that they do deserve to be left in their underdeveloped and backward states. I have previously published (this REVIEW, xxxvi, November I 9 54, 3 8 7-89) some thoughts on public expenditure theory; and in order to widen the discussion among economic theorists, I later gave a non-mathematical exposition (ibid., XXXVII, November I955, 350-56). I do not propose here to give a detailed review of these theories. Rather, I'd like to think aloud about some of the difficulties with expenditure theory and with political decision-making. On these subjects, Richard Musgrave and Julius Margolis have done outstanding research and I must confess my obligation to them for much friendly counsel.
The Review of Economics and Statistics195840(4), 431
What is the exact nature of the consumption function? Can this term be defined so that it will be consistent with empirical evidence and a valid instrument in the hands of future economic researchers and policy makers? In this volume a distinguished American economist presents a new theory of the consumption function, tests it against extensive statistical J material and suggests some of its significant implications.Central to the new theory is its sharp distinction between two concepts of income, measured income, or that which is recorded for a particular period, and permanent income, a longer-period concept in terms of which consumers decide how much to spend and how much to save. Milton Friedman suggests that the total amount spent on consumption is on the average the same fraction of permanent income, regardless of the size of permanent income. The magnitude of the fraction depends on variables such as interest rate, degree of uncertainty relating to occupation, ratio of wealth to income, family size, and so on.The hypothesis is shown to be consistent with budget studies and time series data, and some of its far-reaching implications are explored in the final chapter.