Knowledge that Transforms

This paper investigates the magnitude of the elasticity of demand for labor in time series data using more general and complete models of demand than have been previously employed. It argues that previous analyses have imposed two invalid constraints in calculations, which bias downward estimated elasticities. The first invalid constraint is the assumption that real capital prices have an equal opposite effect to real wages in the demand equation. We show on measurement error grounds that this constraint should not be imposed in econometric work even when longrun homogeneity of prices correctly characterizes the market. The constraint is rejected in the data. The second invalid constraint is that all explanatory variables have the same lag distribution. We argue that this constraint is invalid when decisions are made under uncertainty and find that it is also rejected by the data. The principal positive empirical finding is that with the constraints relaxed, the elasticity, of demand with respect to real wages is much larger than the estimates in the literature, indicating much greater price responsiveness on the demand side of the labor market than has previously been thought.

Truncated Normal, Econometrica 42 (Nov. 1974), 999-1011. Dagenais, Marcel, Application of a Threshold Regression Model to Household Purchases of Automobiles, this REVIEW 57 (Aug. 1975), 275-285. Goldfeld, Stephen, and Richard Quandt, Estimation in a Disequilibrium Model and the Value of Information, Journal of Econometrics 3 (1975), 325-348. Hausman, Jerry, and David Wise, Evaluation of Results from Truncated Samples: The New Jersey Income Maintenance Experiment, Annals of Economic and Measurement 5 (1976), 421-445. , Social Experimentation, Truncated Distributions, and Efficient Estimation, Econometrica 45 (May 1977), 919-938. Heckman, James, Shadow Prices, Market Wages, and Labor Supply, Econometrica 42 (July 1974), 679694. , Common Structure of Statistical Models of Truncation, Sample Selection, and Limited Dependent Variables and a Simple Estimator for Such Models, Annals of Economic and Measurement 5 (1976), 475-492. Keeley, Michael, Philip Robins, Robert Spiegelman, and Richard West, Labor Supply Effects and Costs of Alternative Negative Income Tax Programs, Journal of Human Resources 13 (Winter 1978), 3-36. Nelson, Forrest, Censored Regression Models with Unobserved, Stochastic Censoring Thresholds, Journal of Econometrics 6 (1977), 309-327. Rosen, Harvey, Taxes in a Labor Supply Model with Joint Wage-Hours Determination, Econometrica 44 (May 1976), 485-507. Rosett, Richard, and Forrest Nelson, Estimation of the Two-Limit Probit Regression Model, Econometrica 43 (Jan. 1975), 141-146. Shishko, Robert, and Bernard Rostker, Economics of Multiple Job Holding, American Economic Review 66 (June 1976), 298-308. Tobin, James, Estimation of Relationships for Limited Dependent Variables, Econometrica 26 (Jan. 1958), 24-36.