To make high-quality research more accessible and easier to explore.

Fields:
23 results ✕ Clear filters

The Effectiveness of Statistical Analytical Review as a Substantive Auditing Procedure: A Simulation Analysis.

The Accounting Review 1988 63(1), 74-95
The purpose of this paper is to assess via simulation the effectiveness of various analytical review procedures when used in combination with a partitioned approach to dollar unit sampling for tests of account details. Seven analytical review procedures based on regression analysis were applied to two sets of simulated accounting data which were seeded with different patterns of known overstatement errors. Audit sample sizes for dollar unit sampling and achieved audit detection risk were then computed based on the analytical review outcomes. There were three major findings in this study. First, regression based analytical review increased audit effectiveness relative to an audit strategy that did not use analytical review. Second, the use of monthly data greatly increased the effectiveness of analytical review. Finally, regression based analytical review models were very efficient in detecting potentially material misstatements.

Accounting Internships and Subsequent Academic Performance: An Empirical Study.

The Accounting Review 1987 62(4), 799-807
This study investigates the impact of student internships on subsequent academic performance. The post-internship course performance of students with internship experience was compared to that of a group of noninterns (matched on grade-point average and hours of coursework completed prior to the internship). Average performance across all courses did not differ significantly between the two groups. Analysis of performance in particular subject areas and courses suggests a tendency for interns to focus their efforts on courses most closely related to their chosen career. However, only in auditing coursework (where substantive knowledge gained from their internship experience should be most applicable) was the performance of interns significantly better than that of the noninterns.

Resource Allocation Decisions in Audit Engagements*

Contemporary Accounting Research 1997 14(3), 481-499
We examine the empirical relationship between auditors' resource allocations and selected engagement characteristics. Our measure of resources is hours of grades of labor (partner, manager, etc.) “charged” to audit activities (planning, internal control evaluation, etc.). Engagement characteristics examined are client size, industry affiliation, client complexity, risk, auditor provision of management advisory services to the auditee, and degree of control reliance. The data were obtained from publicly available sources and a survey developed and administered by an international public accounting firm. We find the cross‐sectional variation in the labor charged to various audit activities can be explained by engagement characteristics found to be important in prior studies on audit fees, total labor inputs, and the mix of labor inputs. Measures of client size, industry, complexity, risk, and services provided are associated with changes in the allocation of labor among audit activities. We find no substitution of internal control review/testing for substantive testing on reliance audits. Task assignments vary by rank. Measures of client size, complexity, risk, and services provided are associated with activity‐specific changes in the labor mix.

Annual Editor Report

The Accounting Review 2022 97(7), 1-19
Views Icon Views Article contents Figures & tables Video Audio Supplementary Data Peer Review Share Icon Share Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Tools Icon Tools Get Permissions Search Site Cite View This Citation Add to Citation Manager Citation W. Robert Knechel; Annual Editor Report. The Accounting Review 1 November 2022; 97 (7): 1–19. https://doi.org/10.2308/accr-10849 Download citation file: Ris (Zotero) Reference Manager EasyBib Bookends Mendeley Papers EndNote RefWorks BibTex toolbar search Search Dropdown Menu toolbar search search input Search input auto suggest filter your search All ContentThe Accounting Review Search Advanced Search

The Effect of Client Industry Agglomerations on Auditor Industry Specialization

Journal of Accounting Research 2023 61(5), 1771-1825
Prior research on auditor industry specialization documents fee premiums for local audit offices that are industry specialists. This research assumes that the effects of specialization are uniform across markets. We examine industry specialization based on the economic theory of industry agglomeration (geographic areas with high industry concentration). Agglomeration economies can facilitate access to knowledge for auditors serving a specific industry in those locations. We find that industry specialists in agglomerations earn a fee premium in excess of specialists in other markets. We find that nonspecialist offices in agglomerations also earn fee premiums in that industry when compared to nonspecialists in other markets even when controlling for these groups’ absolute share of the national market. We also address whether or not this expertise can be shared among offices in an agglomeration specialist's firm. We find that audit offices that have easy connections to a within‐firm office in an agglomerated market can earn a fee premium relative to more distant offices, suggesting a benefit from knowledge transfer. This fee premium accrues to offices that would not be considered a specialist using traditional market share measures in a given industry. These findings indicate that the benefit of industry specialization depends on more than local market share.

If You Want My Advice: Status Motives and Audit Consultations About Accounting Estimates

Journal of Accounting Research 2016 54(5), 1331-1364
Effective consultation is critical for improving the audit of estimates. In an experiment where audit managers acted as consultants to other auditors, we examine conditions in which consultants either recommend estimates that differ substantially from advice-seekers’ assessments (contrariness) or recommend narrower reasonable ranges of estimates (precision). Psychology theory argues that both of these attributes can improve estimates. We examine whether these attributes depend on consultants' status motives, that is, the desire to gain respect from or power over others. We find that active status motives lead consultants with higher specialized knowledge to provide recommendations that are less contrary, but more precise. However, consultants increase precision by tightening range bounds in a manner that is not counter to management's preference and thus unlikely to prompt the audit team to challenge the estimate. We also find that higher consultant decision authority constrains precision. Our findings suggest limits to consultation's potential effectiveness in improving estimates. For instance, our findings suggest that firms and standard setters direct consultants to focus scrutiny on the range bound that is most likely to constrain management opportunism.