Abstract ABSTRACT: This paper presents a framework for empirical research on the self-selection and effort effects on worker performance of standard-based employment contracts, along with the results of an experiment that tests some hypotheses derived within the framework. The framework examines how personal and contract attributes (or a worker's perceptions of them) affect the self-selection process and how self-selection and effort are interdependent. The experimental results were consistent with these hypotheses: workers select among alternative employment contracts based on their performance capability, the correlation between performance capability and performance incentives in the contract selected is higher in the presence of a controllability filter, and contract selection can explain effort effects.
Abstract ABSTRACT: This study focuses on the influence of qualified opinions on auditor switches. Results from a random sample of SEC-registrants support the contention that firms switch auditors more frequently after receiving qualified opinions. However, it was not found that firms that have received qualified opinions switch systematically to audit firms with a history of rendering proportionally fewer qualified opinions. Also, limited results suggest that qualified firms which switch auditors do not tend subsequently to receive more clean opinions.
Abstract. This experimental study tests the predicted effects of three performance‐contingent pay schemes on subordinate misrepresentations: profit sharing, a single‐subordinate truth‐inducing scheme, and the Groves scheme. A contribution not found in prior experimental research is the introduction of the distinction between direct and indirect misrepresentations. The results show that, as predicted, the three schemes have different abilities to deter the two types of misrepresentations. The fewest direct and indirect misrepresentations occur under the Groves scheme and the most under the linear profit‐sharing scheme. There is no significant difference between the single‐subordinate truth‐inducing scheme and the Groves scheme in the incidence of direct misrepresentations, but indirect misrepresentations are significantly more frequent under the former. Résumé. La présente étude expérimentale vise à tester certaines hypothèses relatives aux résultats de l'application de trois structures salariales liées au rendement sur les déclarations trompeuses des subordonnés: la participation linéaire aux bénéfices, une structure salariale individuelle favorisant la franchise et la structure Groves. Cette étude se démarque des etudes expérimentales antérieures en ce qu'elle introduit une distinction entre l'information trompeuse directe et indirecte. Les résultats révèlent que, conformément aux hypothèses, les trois structures salariales présentent des capacités différentes de décourager les deux formes de déclarations trompeuses. La structure Groves est celle qui occasionne le plus petit nombre de déclarations trompeuses directes et indirectes, tandis que la participation linéaire aux bénéfices est celle qui en occasionne le plus. Il n'existe pas de différence significative entre la structure salariale individuelle favorisant la franchise et la structure Groves en ce qui a trait à l'occurrence des déclarations trompeuses directes, mais les déclarations trompeuses indirectes sont beaucoup plus fréquentes dans le cas de la structure salariale individuelle.
Abstract ABSTRACT: This paper provides empirical evidence on a truth-inducing pay scheme widely discussed and analyzed in the Incentive contracting literature. An experiment was conducted in which subjects acted as subordinates who performed e production task. Budgets were participatively set under either a truth-inducing or slack-inducing pay scheme and either the presence or absence of a superior-subordinate Information asymmetry about subordinate performance capability. Slack was defined as expected performance minus the participatively set budget. The results showed that, when the information asymmetry was absent, slack did not differ significantly between the pay schemes. However, when the Information asymmetry was present, slack was significantly lower under the truth-inducing scheme. Similarly, the pay scheme and information asymmetry variables Interacted to affect performance.