To make high-quality research more accessible and easier to explore.

Fields:

Competitive Selection and Market Data: The Mixed-Index Problem

Review of Economic Studies 1992 59(3), 625
If prices have an allocational role, then in addition to their economic signalling, they may act as a statistical signal for the existence of selection bias in cross-sectional studies with some form of price (wages, rental, yield etc.) as dependent variable. Elements of competitive selection appear in the pricing theory of real or financial assets and in the determination of wage rates, where prices correlate the characteristics of the asset or job with those of the individuals, under the equilibrium allocation. If prices achieve such an allocation, then regressions with price as dependent variable are prima facie "mixed-index" in character, with adverse bias or consistency properties, no matter that the right-hand regressors are apparently exogenous. We set up a paradigm for competitive selection and use the concepts so generated to codify the conditions under which mixed index bias will occur. The problem may be regarded as one of selection bias, but does not necessarily derive from classical simultaneity, and is a problem of data-generation structures rather than sample selection.