To make high-quality research more accessible and easier to explore.

Fields:
5 results

Is Institutional Research on Management Accounting Degenerating or Progressing? A Lakatosian Analysis*

Contemporary Accounting Research 2022 39(4), 2560-2595 open access
Adopting a Lakatosian perspective, this paper asks whether management accounting (MA) research using institutional theory can be described as a degenerative or progressive research program. Motivated by similar critical debates about the larger institutional research program in organization studies, I map the evolution of institutional research on MA with an eye to its theoretical contributions to the accounting literature as well as this larger research program. I conclude that this body of research has offered important, progressive extensions to the accounting literature and, to a lesser extent, the larger institutional research program. However, there is also evidence of many MA scholars using institutional theory in ways that produce degenerative tendencies. These degenerative tendencies are, in large part, due to the persistent proclivity of researchers to place overly one‐sided emphasis on the role of either human agency or preexisting institutions in explaining the process of (de‐)institutionalization and may, at worst, cause functionalist assumptions to be smuggled back into institutional analyses in ways that threaten the hard core of the institutional research program. I discuss how these tendencies can be rectified in future research and how institutional research on MA can be further developed.

Bringing culture back in: An institutional analysis of budgeting and power in an emerging economy context

Accounting, Organizations and Society 2027 118, 101676 open access
This paper examines how notions of culture and power intertwine in the shaping of budget-related practices within a large public sector organisation in Bangladesh. Drawing on institutional theory, we advance a view of power as a dynamic and relational, yet institutionally embedded, phenomenon. We examine how the power originating in cultural norms, which are firmly institutionalised in Bangladeshi society, is reinforced and weakened by micro-level dynamics in the organisation under investigation. We also show how the interplay between cultural norms and micro-level dynamics is conditioned by the influence of international donor agencies and other actors, who are relatively peripheral to the organisation, and how this gives rise to variations in the operation of power and budget-related practices. Examining how this interplay manifests itself under conditions of institutional stability, we provide a nuanced perspective on how power is implicated in budgeting and a systematic, contingent conception of how variations in budget-related practices emerge. We discuss the implications for institutional research on budgeting and institutional theory in general.