← Search

The Accounting Review Vol. 99 No. 3 2024

How Trial Preparation Factors Influence Audit Litigation Outcomes: Insights from Audit Litigators

Eldar Maksymov1; Mark E. Peecher2; Jeffrey S. Pickerd3; Yuepin Zhou2

1 Arizona State University · 2 University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign · 3 The University of Mississippi

open access

Abstract

Research indicates that auditors have an impoverished understanding of trial preparation factors that, independent of audit quality, can significantly elevate audit litigation risk. As the scholarly literature sheds little insight about the nature and implications of these factors, we identify what factors audit litigators consider in trial preparation, how they expect these factors to affect litigation outcomes, and how they attempt to leverage these factors. To do so, we interview 39 audit litigators, who identify factors germane to trial venues, jury pools, and case arguments. Guided by the elaboration likelihood model, we construct a framework that predicts these factors influence litigation outcomes by changing jurors’ motivation and/or capability to elaborate. Importantly, we find that litigators who defend (sue) auditors strategically maneuver these factors to increase (decrease) the likelihood of higher juror elaboration, because higher elaboration is favorable to auditors. We discuss implications of our results for practice and research.

DOI
10.2308/tar-2021-0305
Volume
99
Issue
3
Pages
373-396
Language
en
Sources
openalex bibtex:phds-export.bib crossref

Cite