← Search

American Economic Review Vol. 113 No. 9 2023

Second-Best Fairness: The Trade-Off between False Positives and False Negatives

Alexander W. Cappelen1; Cornelius Cappelen2; Bertil Tungodden1

1 Department of Economics, NHH Norwegian School of Economics (email: ) · 2 Department of Comparative Politics, University of Bergen (email: )

Abstract

A main focus in economics is how to design optimal policies in second-best situations, which often requires a trade-off between giving some individuals more than they deserve, false positives, and others less than they deserve, false negatives. This paper provides novel evidence on people’s second-best fairness preferences from large-scale experimental studies in the United States and Norway. The majority of people are more concerned with false negatives than with false positives, but we document substantial heterogeneity in second-best fairness preferences between the countries and across the political spectrum. The findings shed light on the political economy of social insurance and redistribution.

DOI
10.1257/aer.20211015
Volume
113
Issue
9
Pages
2458-2485
Language
en
Sources
openalex bibtex:phds-export.bib crossref

Cite