← Search

Quarterly Journal of Economics Vol. 138 No. 3 2023

Justifying Dissent

Leonardo Bursztyn1; Georgy Egorov2; Ingar Haaland3; Aakaash Rao4; Christopher Roth5

1 University of Chicago and National Bureau of Economic Research , United States · 2 Kellogg School of Management and National Bureau of Economic Research , United States · 3 NHH Norwegian School of Economics, Norway · 4 Harvard University, United States · 5 University of Cologne and Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods, Germany, and Centre for Economic Policy and Research , United Kingdom

Abstract

Dissent plays an important role in any society, but dissenters are often silenced through social sanctions. Beyond their persuasive effects, rationales providing arguments supporting dissenters’ causes can increase the public expression of dissent by providing a “social cover” for voicing otherwise stigmatized positions. Motivated by a simple theoretical framework, we experimentally show that liberals are more willing to post a tweet opposing the movement to defund the police, are seen as less prejudiced, and face lower social sanctions when their tweet implies they had first read credible scientific evidence supporting their position. Analogous experiments with conservatives demonstrate that the same mechanisms facilitate anti-immigrant expression. Our findings highlight both the power of rationales and their limitations in enabling dissent and shed light on phenomena such as social movements, political correctness, propaganda, and antiminority behavior.

DOI
10.1093/qje/qjad007
Volume
138
Issue
3
Pages
1403-1451
Language
en
Sources
bibtex:phds-export.bib openalex crossref

Cite