← Search

Quarterly Journal of Economics Vol. 140 No. 4 2025

Conviction, Incarceration, and Recidivism: Understanding the Revolving Door

John Eric Humphries1; Aurélie Ouss2; Kamelia Stavreva3; Megan T Stevenson4; Winnie van Dijk1

1 Yale University and National Bureau of Economic Research · 2 University of Pennsylvania and National Bureau of Economic Research , · 3 Columbia University · 4 University of Virginia

Abstract

Noncarceral conviction is a common outcome of criminal court cases: for every person incarcerated, there are approximately three who were recently convicted but not sentenced to prison or jail. We extend the binary-treatment judge IV framework to settings with multiple treatments and use it to study the consequences of noncarceral conviction. We outline assumptions under which widely used 2SLS regressions recover margin-specific treatment effects, relate these assumptions to models of judge decision-making, and derive an expression that provides intuition about the direction and magnitude of asymptotic bias when a key assumption on judge decision-making is not met. We find that noncarceral conviction (relative to dismissal) leads to a large and long-lasting increase in recidivism for felony defendants in Virginia. In contrast, incarceration (relative to noncarceral conviction) leads to a short-run reduction in recidivism, consistent with incapacitation. Our empirical results suggest that noncarceral felony conviction is an important and overlooked driver of recidivism.

DOI
10.1093/qje/qjaf040
Volume
140
Issue
4
Pages
2907-2962
Language
en
Sources
bibtex:phds-export.bib openalex crossref

Cite