← Search

Quarterly Journal of Economics Vol. 136 No. 3 2021

Do You Know that I Know that You Know…? Higher-Order Beliefs in Survey Data

Olivier Coibion1; Yuriy Gorodnichenko2; Saten Kumar3; Jane Ryngaert4

1 University of Texas at Austin and National Bureau of Economic Research, United States · 2 University of California at Berkeley and National Bureau of Economic Research, United States · 3 Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand · 4 Wake Forest University, United States

open access

Abstract

We implement a new survey of firms, focusing on their higher-order macroeconomic expectations. The survey provides a novel set of stylized facts regarding the relationship between first-order and higher-order expectations of economic agents, including how they adjust their beliefs in response to a variety of information treatments. We show how these facts can be used to calibrate key parameters of noisy-information models with infinite regress as well as to test predictions made by this class of models. We also consider a range of extensions to the basic noisy-information model that can potentially better reconcile theory and empirics. Although some extensions like level-k thinking are unsuccessful, incorporating heterogeneous long-run priors can address the empirical shortcomings of the basic noisy-information model.

DOI
10.1093/qje/qjab005
Volume
136
Issue
3
Pages
1387-1446
Language
en
Sources
bibtex:phds-export.bib openalex crossref

Cite