← Search

Review of Financial Studies 2025

Relative Performance Evaluation and Strategic Competition

Li He1; Toni M. Whited2; Ran Guo3

1 Indiana University · 2 University of Michigan and NBER · 3 Shanghai Advanced Institute of Finance , Shanghai Jiao Tong University,

Abstract

We examine how relative performance evaluation (RPE) affects industry competition—a question relevant for corporate boards interested in incentivizing executives. Using U.S. airline data, we estimate a dynamic game of competition between heterogeneous firms in an oligopolistic market, with managers incentivized by RPE contracts. While RPE can induce a firm to compete more intensely by smoothing compensation, it also amplifies a firm’s cost efficiency relative to its peers and can weaken competition from inefficient firms. The first effect dominates in small markets and the second in median-sized markets. RPE has little effect in large, highly profitable markets.

DOI
10.1093/rfs/hhaf028
Language
en
Sources
crossref openalex

Cite