The Review of Economics and Statistics Vol. 50 No. 1 1968
Some Evidence on the Small Sample Properties of Distributed Lag Estimators in the Presence of Autocorrelated Disturbances
Abstract
where ut is a random disturbance with zero mean. Koyck pointed out that subtracting Xyt-i from (1) produced the equation yt = A'+xyt_i+ bxt+ut' (2) where A' = A(1 -X) and ut' = ut -Xut1. Thus instead of being forced to deal with the model in its distributed lag form (1), which involves the seemingly intractable task of estimating a relation with an infinite number of explanatory variables from a finite amount of data, we can estimate the parameters of the autoregressive form of the model given in equation (2). However, this apparent simplification is purchased only at a cost, for consistent estimation of relation (2) requires that we face several estimation problems associated with equations in which lagged dependent variables appear as explanatory variables. While ordinary least squares estimates of the parameters of (2) are consistent provided that the disturbances ut' are serially independent and follow a distribution which satisfies the assumptions of the central limit theorem, even in this case a small sample bias exists. If the disturbances are serially dependent, an asymptotic bias exists.' Moreover, the transformation from (1) to (2) has changed both the variance and the serial correlations of the disturbances. Hence, if the disturbances in (1) are serially independent, those in (2) are necessarily autocorrelated, which means that applying least squares to equation (2) yields inconsistent estimates of the parameters. In addition to ordinary least squares (OLS), several techniques for estimating such distributed lag relations are available. Generally these techniques have been recommended on the basis of their desirable asymptotic properties. However, for economists, who are forced to work in a world where data are scarce, asymptotic properties are frequently of little relevance. What is more often required is knowledge of the properties of the estimators in small samples. Unfortunately, it has proved difficult to investigate these properties analytically. In the absence of such results, sampling or Monte Carlo experiments provide an alternative, if less elegant, source of information. Accordingly, this paper presents the results of a Monte Carlo study of several lag estimators under conditions in which the disturbances ut' of relation (2) are serially correlated. In addition to ordinary least squares, the following five methods were studied. 1) Two Stage Regression (TSLS): This is an application of Leviatan's instrumental variable approach. Leviatan [12] has suggested that xti1 be used as an instrument for yt-i in estimating relation (2). In order to increase the efficiency of the technique, we employed a linear combination of lagged x's as the instrument. The linear combination was determined by first estimating the equation
- DOI
- 10.2307/1927059
- Volume
- 50
- Issue
- 1
- Pages
- 87
- Sources
- openalex crossref