Journal of Consumer Research 2025

The Robin Hood Effect in Transgressions Against Firms: How Political Ideology Shapes Consumer Justifications

Jason D Lin¹; Anat Keinan¹; Hannah H. Chang²; Donald R. Lehmann³

¹ Boston University · ² Singapore Management University · ³ Columbia University

Abstract

Consumer transgressions against firms involve moral violations in which consumers take advantage of loopholes in companies’ return and satisfaction-guaranteed policies or the lack of strict enforcement against password sharing, piracy, shoplifting, wardrobing, coupon stacking, promotion abuse, and fraud. Drawing on the timeless tale of Robin Hood, the legendary outlaw who stands up against injustice, the authors demonstrate that consumers use a Robin Hood justification to legitimize their transgressions against firms. Building on moral foundations theory, this research demonstrates that political ideology impacts consumers’ transgression behavior and the perceived morality of these practices. Six studies show that under certain conditions in which the moral virtues of fairness and care are cued, liberals are more likely to engage in transgressions than conservatives. The studies further test factors that can intensify or mitigate consumer transgressions against firms. Findings from this research can help marketers better understand how consumers justify transgressions and how to effectively reduce these costly and pervasive behaviors.

DOI

10.1093/jcr/ucaf053

Sources

openalex