Circuitousness in Disclosure Narratives
Abstract
This paper examines circuitousness, which reflects related information being spread throughout a narrative as opposed to being grouped together. Circuitousness in the MD&A is higher for underperforming firms facing an imminent recovery, a difficult scenario for managers to describe and reconcile. Such firms’ disclosures are accompanied by heightened information processing activity, such as EDGAR downloads and analyst forecast revisions. Additionally, initial return reactions are faster but incomplete, consistent with recoveries and the ensuing circuitousness increasing processing costs that delay price discovery. Changes in institutional ownership are concentrated among quasi-indexers, who rely on public disclosure but rebalance only gradually. Circuitousness is incrementally and more consistently predictive than other textual characteristics that are related but are typically associated with obfuscation, such as the Fog index and repetition. Overall, circuitousness in financial disclosure signals that a turnaround is imminent and corresponds to more costly information processing.
- DOI
- 10.2308/tar-2023-0731
- Pages
- 1-39
- Language
- en
- Sources
- crossref