Journal of Banking & Finance Vol. 192 2026
The 52-week high liquidity mirage: How behavioral convergence impairs price discovery
Abstract
This study examines whether trading patterns at the 52-week high reflect investor disagreement or behavioral convergence. Using StockTwits sentiment, TAQ microstructure data, and machine-learning-informed trading measures for S&P 500 stocks, we document that investor beliefs converge rather than diverge, thereby reducing disagreement by approximately 20%. Belief dispersion falls while both retail and institutional investors proportionally reduce trading and shift toward selling. Anchoring to the 52-week high generates a liquidity mirage, concentrated among the largest stocks where competitive market making prevails: effective spreads narrow and depth increases even as informed-trading intensity declines, consistent with adverse selection models but driven by behavioral convergence. Although liquidity appears to improve, price discovery weakens, and the stock subsequently underperforms characteristic and factor benchmarks by 20 to 30 basis points over five days. Our findings demonstrate how improvements in liquidity can coincide with weaker price discovery when investor beliefs converge around salient behavioral anchors.
- DOI
- 10.1016/j.jbankfin.2026.107830
- Volume
- 192
- Pages
- 107830
- Language
- en
- Sources
- crossref openalex