Apparently mistaken decisions are ubiquitous. To what extent does this reflect irrationality, as opposed to a rational trade-off between the costs of information acquisition and the expected benefits of learning? We develop a revealed preference test that characterizes all patterns of choice “mistakes” consistent with a general model of optimal costly information acquisition and identify the extent to which information costs can be recovered from choice data.
How and to what extent “neuroeconomic” data (broadly interpreted as data other than standard choice data) should be used in advancing economic theory is open to question. Several authors have attempted to make use of such nonstandard data to shed light on the process of economic decision making. John W. Payne, James R. Bettman, and Eric. J. Johnson (1993), Miguel Costa Gomes, Vincent P. Crawford, and Bruno Broseta (2001), and Xavier Gabaix et al. (2006) have used MouseLab software in order to determine the manner in which people use information. Joseph Wang, Michael Spezio, and Colin Camerer (2006) make use of eye-tracking data for the same purpose. More dramatically, researchers such as Paul William Glimcher, Joseph Kable, and Kenway Louie (2007) are using brain-scanning data in an attempt to constrain economic models of discounting and time preference. Camerer (forthcoming) presents an excellent review of economic research involving nonstandard data. In opposition to this trend, Faruk Gul and Wolfgang Pesendorfer (forthcoming) present a strong critique of the use of nonchoice data within economics. They put forward two specific arguments that users of “neuroeconomic” data must refute if their work is to be taken seriously. First—economic models were designed only to explain choices. Thus, nonchoice data can be used neither to confirm nor deny a particular economic model. Second, it is by and large true that economists are interested in choice behavior. Any two models will either make different predictions for choice, in which case they can be differentiated by standard choice data, or they will not, in which case an economist will not be interested in differentiating between them. Economic Insights from “Neuroeconomic” Data
Paul Glimcher (2003) and Colin Camerer, George Loewenstein, and Drazen Prelec (2005) make powerful cases in favor of neuroeconomic research. Yet in their equally powerful defense of standard “Mindless Economics,” Faruk Gul and Wolfgang Pesendorfer (forthcoming) point to the profound language gap between the two contributing disciplines. For example, for an economist, risk aversion captures preferences among wealth lotteries. From the neuroscientific viewpoint, it is a broader concept related to fear responses and the amygdala. Furthermore, as economic models make no predictions concerning brain activity, neurological data can neither support nor refute these models. Rather than looking to connect such distinct abstractions, Gul and Pesendorfer (forthcoming) argue for explicit separation: “The requirement that economic theories simultaneously account for economic data and brain imaging data places an unreasonable burden on economic theories.” We share the conviction of Glimcher (2003) and Camerer, Loewenstein, and Prelec (2005) concerning the potential value of neuroeconomics, yet we believe that the field will live up to its potential only if a common conceptual language can be agreed upon. Hence, we face the Gul and Pesendorfer challenge head on by developing theories that simultaneously account for behavioral and brain imaging data. The principal innovation lies in our use of the decision theorists’ standard axiomatic methodology in this highly nonstandard setting. This removes any linguistic confusion by defining concepts directly in terms of their empirical counterparts. It also allows us to pinpoint how to design experiments directed to the central tenets of the theory, rather than to particular parametrizations. If these experimental tests reveal the theory to be wanting, then knowing which axiom is The Neuroeconomic Theory of Learning
Many everyday decisions are made without full examination of all available options, and, as a result, the best available option may be missed. We develop a search-theoretic choice experiment to study the impact of incomplete consideration on the quality of choices. We find that many decisions can be understood using the satisficing model of Herbert Simon (1955): most subjects search sequentially, stopping when a “satisficing” level of reservation utility is realized. We find that reservation utilities and search order respond systematically to changes in the decision making environment.