Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(2), 95-133
We analyze the value to firms of being able to renegotiate covenants in their debt contracts. Covenants control agency problems, but also reduce firms' flexibility to pursue profitable investments. Initial covenants will be more severe for renegotiable contracts, because they can be relaxed selectively when the lender believes they pose an inefficient constraint. We show firms with high ex ante credit risk find the option to renegotiate most valuable. The model is used to explain why bank loans and privately placed debt typically have harsher covenants than public debt and to predict which firms will borrow using closely held debt. Journal of Economic Literature Classification Numbers: D82, G21, G32.
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(1), 83-93
This paper evaluates the economies of scale and scope in the French mutual funds (SICAV) industry. This segment of the financial sector offers the unique characteristic that some firms specialize, while others supply several products. The results suggest economies of scale and scope for small institutions and diseconomies for larger firms. An appropriate size for a diversified company is in the range of FF 2.9 billion
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(3), 255-276
In this paper we analyze how depositors can employ both monitoring and capital requirements to control the risk of bank assets. We also analyze how monitors should be compensated if their actions are not directly observable and if there are binding limits on their liability. Second-best capital and monitoring levels (with unobservable actions) will be distorted away from their respective first-best levels. We derive some results about the nature of these distortions and characterize the optimal incentive scheme for monitors
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(3), 237-254
This paper shows that a debt contract with warrants for the lender and cash/equity settlement options for the entrepreneur-borrower is the optimal contract in a setting with moral hazard and unverifiable states of nature. This contract makes it possible to contract optimally ex ante on unverifiable states; debt obligations are adjusted to state realizations so that debt is made safer. Moral hazard is reduced as a result
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(4), 347-375
We examine the design of compensation contracts and determination of investment policies when a manager has private information regarding the effect of investment on both the firm's cash flows and the private benefits she is able to extract from employment. We show that, in general, the optimal mechanism is characterized by a menu of salary and option contracts. When the manager's private information relates only to the firm's cash flows, the firm overinvests relative to the Pareto optimal level. On the other hand, if the private information relates only to private benefits, the firm will underinvest.
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(3), 277-307
This paper studies distinctions between fixed-price and Dutch auction self-tenders for common stock. We find that fixed-price tenders pay higher premiums to retire greater equity fractions than Dutch offers yet generate similar total returns to stockholders. Accordingly, total returns are significantly higher in Dutch auctions after controlling for tender and firm characteristics. In addition, wealth transfers to owners of repurchased shares are significantly higher in fixed-price offers. The Dutch mechanism thus appears to induce increases in firm value with smaller disbursals of cash. These cost savings to investors who maintain their ownership may explain the popularity of the new technique
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(4), 422-448open access
This paper develops a model of security broker behavior under price uncertainty. The model examines the process of matching orders and the determinants of equilibrium brokerage commission rates. Institutional arrangements, search efficiency, execution costs, volume, risk, and the unit price of the security are shown to affect equilibrium brokerage commission rates. Some stylized facts of security brokerage are explained
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(4), 376-400
This paper analyzes the optimal financial structure for a firm in which the top manager must provide incentives to a subordinate in addition to exerting directly productive efforts. Optimal capital structure is shown to involve a moderate level of debt with a substantial penalty for default, and passive shareholders. In a two- or three-layer hierarchy, optimal leverage is shown to decrease as either the number of hierarchical levels or the importance of agents further down the hierarchy increases. This and other implications of the model square well with existing evidence and suggest new directions for empirical work
Journal of Financial Intermediation19922(2), 134-167
A model with private information that supports conventional arguments for a government monopoly in supplying circulating media of exchange is constructed. The model also yields rate-of-return and velocity predictions which are consistent with observations from free banking regimes and fiat money regimes. In a laissezfaire banking equilibrium, fiat money is (essentially) not valued, and the resulting allocation is not Pareto optimal. However, if private agents are restricted from issuing circulating notes, there exists an equilibrium with valued fiat money that Pareto dominates the laissez-faire equilibrium and is Pareto optimal within a restricted class of allocations. Journal of Economic Literature Classification Numbers: 020, 310.
The commitment value of financial contracts is limited by the ability of contracting parties to renegotiate them away, if it becomes mutually beneficial to do so. When debt contracts are used by oligopolistic firms to commit to aggressive output strategies as in Brander-Lewis, we show that renegotiation may undermine commitment under symmetric information, but not generally under asymmetric information. Lasting contracts that survive renegotiation are proposed. It is shown that there exist lasting debt contracts which preserve the commitment value and in which not all debt is renegotiated away.